AI summarizes book on Jehovah's Witness Founder Charles Taze Russell's connection to Jewish Zionists - BWS Book Club 1.6 - Pastor Charles Taze Russell: An early American Christian Zionist by David Horowitz

 See Table Of Contents

Pastor Charles Taze Russell: An Early American Christian Zionist (second printing, Shengold Publishers, New York, 1990; originally inspired by Emily Hoefle and dedicated to her late husband, Pilgrim John J. Hoefle) is a compilation by David Horowitz, longtime editor of the United Israel Bulletin (UIB, founded 1944). The UIB promotes Mosaic Law for one world and emphasizes biblical prophecies concerning the return of the Children of Israel (all twelve tribes) to their ancient homeland, with Jerusalem as capital. Horowitz presents the volume as a tribute to loyal Bible Students worldwide who uphold Russell’s original teachings—especially his pro-Zionist, pro-Jewish prophetic views—while documenting how his successors (Jehovah’s Witnesses) betrayed them.The book draws heavily from UIB articles (many from the 1970s–1980s) that revived interest in Russell after his death in 1916. It includes historical analysis, excerpts from Russell’s writings and speeches, personal testimonies from devotees, contrasts with post-Russell Watch Tower changes, and appendices on prophecy. It portrays Russell as a pioneering American Christian Zionist who preceded Theodor Herzl in publicly advocating the Jewish return to Zion on biblical grounds and correctly foresaw Israel’s rebirth as fulfillment of prophecy.Russell’s Life and Early Quest for Truth (Chapter 1)Charles Taze Russell was born in 1852 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, the second son of Joseph L. and Ann Eliza (Birney) Russell. As a child in a Congregational/Presbyterian environment, he absorbed doctrines like eternal torment in a literal lake of fire. By his mid-teens, he accepted only what his sectarian ministers taught and viewed questioning doctrine as equivalent to doubting (and thus damning).At around age 15–17, he attempted to convert an infidel acquaintance using Scripture but was routed by skillful questions and paradoxical verses. This led him to skepticism; he discarded the Bible along with creeds. He then investigated leading Oriental religions but found them unconvincing. At 21, burdened by business responsibilities, he still sought truth about the hereafter.He decided to test the Bible skeptically on hell-fire and brimstone. Amazed by its harmonious testimony, he undertook systematic study and regained full confidence in the Bible as inspired by a just, loving Creator. He concluded that creeds had misrepresented Scripture.Russell became president of the Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society (organized 1881/1884; he was sole editor of The Watch Tower from 1879 until his death). He also led the Peoples Pulpit Association (1909) and International Bible Students Association (London, 1913). His major work, the six-volume Studies in the Scriptures (originally Millennial Dawn, retitled 1904), plus other books, booklets, sermons, and tracts, circulated over 16 million copies in 35+ languages—second only to the Bible in distribution at the time.He organized a lecture bureau with ~70 traveling Bible lecturers, wrote most of the Bible Students Monthly (50 million copies annually), and had weekly sermons syndicated in over 2,000 newspapers (combined circulation ~15 million at peak; over 4,000 papers total carried them). He never claimed to found a new religion or receive special revelation; he held it was “God’s due time” for the Bible to be understood. He died October 31, 1916.Russell’s Pro-Zionist Stand and Theology (Chapters 2–3, 11)A 1963 Herzl Year Book article by Yona Malachy (Israeli Ministry of Religious Affairs) details Russell’s role. Influenced by Adventism (William Miller’s failed 1844 prediction), Russell formed Bible study circles, calculated prophetic dates (e.g., 1914 as start of God’s kingdom in Three Worlds, 1877), and published The Object and Manner of the Lord’s Return (1874). He saw the Bible as containing God’s secret plans for humanity and the Millennium.Crucially, Russell viewed the Jewish people as “God’s timepiece”—the Creator’s barometer for events—and stressed their return to the ancestral homeland (Holy Land, Jerusalem as capital) as central to biblical prophecy and the divine plan for blessing “all families of the earth” (Abrahamic Covenant). He taught this from the 1870s–1880s onward, before Herzl’s Der Judenstaat (1896) or the First Zionist Congress (1897). He hailed Zionism as prophetic fulfillment and called Herzl a man “raised up by Providence” as a leader for the Jews.In March 1971, Horowitz’s UIB article (“Founder of Anti-Zionist J-Witnesses Hailed Zionism as Being Biblically Prophetic”) highlighted this. It recounted Russell’s 1910 Hippodrome address (detailed below) and contrasted it with modern Jehovah’s Witnesses’ anti-Zionist stance. Russell quoted Amos 9:11–15 on restoring “the tabernacle of David,” replanting Israel so they “shall no more be pulled up,” and saw Israel’s regathering as the start of restitution (“to the Jew first”). He warned of continued “Jacob’s trouble” (pogroms, tribulations from “professed Christians”) but ultimate divine deliverance and exaltation.The Historic Hippodrome Speech (October 9, 1910; Chapters 3, 8, 13)Invited by prominent New York Jewish leaders (including editors of The Warheit, The Maccabean, etc.), Russell addressed ~4,000 Jews at the packed Hippodrome on “Zionism in Prophecy.” The stage had no religious symbols—only a lectern and peace flags. He declared prophecy proving itself through the Jewish people, through whom blessings would extend to “every nation, people, kindred, and tongue” per the Abrahamic promise/oath.He noted he had tried ~30 years earlier (circa 1880) to tell Israel “God’s set time to remember Zion had come,” but it was “too early.” About 20 years prior (circa 1890), “Providence raised up a great leader, Dr. Herzl,” whose message of national hope and aspiration quickened Jewish hearts when Russell’s earlier message could not. Russell praised Herzl’s aim to make loyal sons of Israel “a nation amongst nations” and provide a home for the persecuted. He predicted Zionism would gain “fresh vigor” and its “most prosperous days are yet to come.”He foresaw more tribulations (“time of ‘Jacob’s trouble’ is not yet ended”; possible further Russian pogroms and atrocities, often from “professed Christians”—a point that shamed him). Yet he comforted per Isaiah 40:1–2: “Comfort ye, comfort ye my people... her warfare is accomplished... she hath received of the Lord’s hand double.” He explicitly stated he was not trying to convert Jews to Christianity or make them members of Catholic/Protestant bodies; God’s promises to Jerusalem were earthly promises to natural Israel. They would return to Palestine as Jews and be established as an independent nation.Eyewitness Raymond G. Jolly (close aide who met Russell in 1909 and worked with him until 1916) described the event: initial cool reception; a caged lion’s roar coinciding with a devil-as-roaring-lion quote caused laughter and shifted the mood; newspapers speculated about “twisting the lion’s tail.” Jolly and his father attended. Russell later clarified via Jewish newspapers that he was not “missioning” the Jews.The speech was historic, reported in papers (e.g., New York American), reproduced in The Bible Student’s Monthly (Dec. 1910), and later translated (e.g., into Malayalam). Devotees preserved and circulated accounts.Reactions, Vindication, and Devotee Support (Chapters 4–5, 8, 12, 14–16, 18)The 1971 UIB articles evoked national/international interest and sold out quickly. Letters poured in from Bible Student groups (e.g., New Albany, Indiana; Chicago; East Los Angeles; Dawn groups; Epiphany/Laymen’s Home Missionary Movement; Israel Commission LHMM), professors, and individuals. They praised Horowitz/UIB for highlighting Russell, affirmed his teachings on Israel’s restoration as prophetic fulfillment (citing Genesis 12:3, Amos 9:15, Jeremiah 30:3, 24:6–7, 31:27–34, Ezekiel, etc.), rejoiced in modern Israel’s progress, and sharply distinguished loyal Bible Students from Jehovah’s Witnesses.Key points repeated: Russell founded the Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society (publishing/coordinating body) and Bible Students movement with congregational autonomy—not a hierarchical sect. He died 1916; “Jehovah’s Witnesses” name and central authority emerged later under J.F. Rutherford. Loyal students (including Jolly, who seceded with Paul S.L. Johnson and R.H. Hirsch to continue the Laymen’s Home Missionary Movement) upheld Russell’s pro-Israel, pro-prophecy stance. Many had personal or family connections to the 1910 Hippodrome meeting or Russell himself.International voices included a French Christian Zionist leader (Gilbert Hermetz) who saw Israel’s rebirth and people’s work on the land as marvelous prophetic fulfillment of promises to “the Land, the Book, and the People.” British and other devotees wrote similarly, seeing Israel’s rebirth as hope for mankind. Laura Kelsey and others noted the UIB “kept memory of Russell alive.” A poem “He Told the Truth” honored Hoefle.Betrayal by Successors and Organizational Turmoil (Chapters 6–7, 9)After Russell’s death, J.F. “Judge” Rutherford (never actually a judge; temporarily elected as such for four days in a Missouri court) seized control. Russell’s will specified board-of-directors control, not one-man rule. Rutherford immediately enacted bylaws giving himself lifetime authority, ejected dissenting directors, and created a self-perpetuating hierarchy—violating Russell’s principles.The organization shifted from publishing/coordinating to centralized “Theocracy” under Rutherford. Many teachings from Studies in the Scriptures were discarded or distorted; “new light” replaced them without honest acknowledgment of changes. The name “Jehovah’s Witnesses” (applying Isaiah 43:12 to themselves) emerged years later; they denied Jews any special post-Jesus role in the divine plan and took anti-Zionist/anti-Israel positions, over-spiritualizing prophecies and claiming themselves as the true heirs.Loyalists (including Moyle, Jolly’s group) opposed these “legal trickeries and radical errors.” Olin R. Moyle (lawyer at Bethel from ~1935, ousted ~1939) sued the Watchtower Society for libel in 1940. The trial (lasting ~3 weeks, ~2,000-page record) exposed control mechanisms, thought control, slander of dissenters, financial irregularities, and Rutherford’s personal habits (women, whiskey). Moyle won; additional evidence of vindictiveness emerged. Rutherford died 1942. Peter O. Moyle (son) later shared details in UIB. Other cases (e.g., Anton Koerber’s suit over loaned funds and evidence destruction) illustrated arbitrary dealings.Chapter 9 explicitly details doctrinal divergences on Israel/Jews and concludes Russell was “neither in principles nor in spirit the founder” of Jehovah’s Witnesses.Hoefle’s Contributions and Prophetic Warnings (Chapters 13, 17, 19–20)Pilgrim John J. Hoefle (Epiphany Bible Students Association, Mount Dora, Florida; died 1984 at 89) was a central figure—loyal Russell champion, close to Paul S.L. Johnson, and dedicatee of the book. His letters/articles in UIB cited the Hippodrome speech, analyzed prophecies (e.g., Joel on Israel’s enemies and deliverance; Nahum’s warning to Nineveh/Assyria as applying to modern militaristic enemies of Israel in the end times), and warned of prophetic fate for Israel’s enemies while affirming God’s protection and ultimate peace (linking Ezekiel 38–39, Zechariah 12/14, etc.). He saw current events (Soviet/Eastern European changes, Jewish immigration to Israel, diminution of Arab-PLO power) as fulfilling Russell’s and biblical forecasts. His widow Emily inspired the revised edition.Appendices

• A: Preview of impending global conflict (prophetic preview from Isaiah, Joel, Jeremiah, Ezekiel, Zechariah of final struggle leading to world peace; Babylon/Assyria reappearing in modern form against Israel).
• B: The Messiah—Who? What? When? (Russell’s views on Messianism and redemption).
• C: Six Interpretations and One Translation (author’s analysis of translation issues and code in Hebrew Bible; Russell’s similar investigative spirit).
• D: David Ben-Gurion Communicates (likely a relevant communication or quote tying into Zionism/Israel’s destiny).

Overall Themes and ConclusionThe book argues that Russell correctly prophesied Israel’s rebirth (vindicated by 1948 and subsequent events, including post-WWII and later immigration waves) when few believed it possible. He stood nearly alone among Christian scholars in his realistic, pro-Jewish, pro-Zionist reading of prophecy, seeing the Jew as central to God’s plan rather than superseded. His voluminous works (translated widely) and the Hippodrome event planted seeds that bore fruit among loyal Bible Students.Successors betrayed this by hierarchical control, doctrinal shifts, and anti-Israel positions—prompting secessions, lawsuits, and ongoing distinctions by groups like Epiphany/LHMM Bible Students. The UIB articles and this volume revive Russell’s voice, showing alignment with biblical prophecy and current events (e.g., Israel’s survival and progress despite “Jacob’s trouble”). Horowitz frames the Bible as a “Blueprint of Life,” with Russell as a faithful witness who told the truth.The tone is appreciative of Russell and loyal devotees, critical of Watch Tower deviations, and hopeful about prophetic fulfillment for Israel and mankind. It includes photos (Russell at 64, with Hoefle, etc.) and preserves primary materials for future generations. The work serves as both historical vindication and call to heed Russell’s (and the prophets’) message: stop, look, and listen to unfolding events centered on Israel.